If you are considering AI Product Photography, this article will be a must read.

Today, technology and creativity intersect more vividly than ever.

Every aspect of business is using AI to cut corners and work faster.

The field of product photography is undergoing that same seismic shift.


Enter Artificial Intelligence (AI)

A legend of science fiction, that is now a reality shaping our visual world.


For marketing professionals, AI in product photography isn’t just a passing trend; it’s a tool with the potential to redefine industry standards.

But, as with all great power, it comes with great responsibility.

Especially when we consider the Federal Trade Commission’s Truth in Advertising Laws.


This will be an exploratory journey through the lens of AI in product photography.

You no longer have to imagine being able to manipulate backgrounds, perfect product imagery, or even extend visual landscapes with a few clicks.

It sounds like a marketer’s dream, right?

But here’s the catch: in a world driven by authenticity, how do we balance the dazzling capabilities of AI with the ethical imperative to represent products truthfully?


This isn’t just a technical discussion; it’s a foray into the ethical landscape of modern marketing.

As we peel away the layers of AI product photography, we’ll discover its potential to enhance efficiency and creativity.

However, we’ll also confront the pivotal question: at what point does enhancement edge into the realm of deception?

And, how do brands navigate this new terrain without losing the trust of their consumers?


From the awe-inspiring feats of AI in transforming imagery to the subtle nuances of maintaining consumer trust, this article promises a deep look into the complexities and wonders of AI product photography.

Whether you’re a seasoned marketing professional or simply fascinated by the intersection of technology and ethics, there’s something here for everyone.

So, keep reading as we unravel the intricate tapestry of AI in the world of product imagery – a journey that promises to be as enlightening as it is challenging.


An example of AI generated imagery.
A good example of AI model imagery. Note the fingers …


The Rise of AI in Product Photography


The world of product photography is witnessing a remarkable transformation, courtesy of Artificial Intelligence (AI).

Once reliant solely on the keen eye and skilled hand of the photographer, photography is now being reshaped by algorithms and machine learning.

This section digs into how AI is redefining product photography, bringing unprecedented efficiency and creativity to the field.


The Advent of AI Tools in Photography


AI in product photography is more than a technological novelty; it’s a paradigm shift.

Tools like automated background removal and object recognition have streamlined the editing process significantly.

What once took hours of meticulous work in a photo studio or with advanced software like Photoshop, can now be achieved in minutes.

But it’s not just about speed – AI brings a level of precision and consistency that is pretty darn good.


Transforming the Creative Process


The impact of AI on the creative process is profound.

By automating routine tasks, AI frees up photographers and marketers to focus on the more creative aspects of their work.

For instance, AI can effortlessly extend backgrounds or change them entirely, enabling photographers to experiment with different aesthetics without the need for elaborate setups.


AI and E-Commerce


AI is particularly impactful in the realm of e-commerce.

Online stores require a constant influx of high-quality product images, and AI tools help meet this demand.

By automating aspects of image editing and enhancement, these tools ensure that products look their best online, which is crucial for attracting customers in a highly visual digital marketplace.


Quality and Quantity: Striking the Right Balance


The integration of AI in product photography also raises questions about quality versus quantity.

While AI enables the production of large volumes of images, it’s essential to maintain a high standard of quality.

A balance needs to be struck where AI aids in meeting the quantitative demands without compromising the aesthetic and authentic representation of the products.


cameras look different but camera exposure settings remain constant across them all.

The Benefits of AI in Product Photography


This section highlights the key advantages that AI brings to the table, particularly for marketing professionals who are constantly seeking innovative ways to showcase products.


Time Efficiency: A Speedy Solution


One of the most significant advantages of using AI in product photography is the remarkable time efficiency it offers.

AI-driven tools can process and edit images at a speed that is simply unattainable manually.

This rapid turnaround is invaluable in a market where time is often of the essence, and the quicker products can be photographed and listed, the faster they can be sold.


Cost-Effectiveness: Saving Resources


AI also presents a cost-effective solution for product photography.

By automating certain aspects of the process, businesses can save on the expenses typically associated with traditional photography, such as studio time, set design, and manual editing.

This reduction in costs can be particularly beneficial for small businesses or startups with limited budgets.


Creative Flexibility: Expanding Horizons


AI introduces a new level of creative flexibility too.

Tools that enable background changes, virtual staging, or even digital model creation open up a world of possibilities for showcasing products in various contexts and styles without the need for physical alterations or elaborate setups.


Accuracy in Editing?


I’m constantly hearing about the precision that AI tools offer in tasks such as cut-outs, color correction, and background extension.

This is supposed to ensure that AI product images are not only aesthetically pleasing but also true to the product’s actual appearance, which is crucial in maintaining consumer trust.

I may be bucking the trend here, but AI still has a way to go on this.

Since this is a section on benefits, I’ll share these opinions a bit later!



The FTC and Truth in Advertising


As AI continues to reshape the landscape of product photography, it’s important to address the legal and ethical framework within which it operates.

Central to this discussion is the Federal Trade Commission’s (FTC) Truth in Advertising Laws, which set the standards for honesty and transparency in marketing practices.


Understanding the FTC’s Truth in Advertising Laws


The FTC’s guidelines are clear: advertisements must be truthful, not misleading, and, when appropriate, backed by scientific evidence.

In the context of product photography, this means that images should accurately represent the product being sold.

The FTC aims to protect consumers from deceptive advertising practices that could mislead them about a product’s features, quality, or usability.


The Relevance to Digital and AI-Generated Images


With digital manipulation and AI-generated images becoming more commonplace, adhering to these laws becomes increasingly complex.

AI offers incredible capabilities for enhancing and modifying product images, but there’s a fine line between making a product look its best and misleading consumers.

For instance, using AI to change the color or texture of a product in a way that misrepresents its real appearance could be considered deceptive under these laws.


Ethical Implications in Marketing


Beyond legal compliance, there’s an ethical dimension to consider.

Consumers expect authenticity from brands, and trust is a crucial component of the consumer-brand relationship.

Excessive or inappropriate use of AI in product photography can lead to a loss of consumer trust, which can have long-term negative impacts on a brand’s reputation.


Best Practices for Compliance


Marketing professionals should ensure that AI-enhanced images are a truthful representation of the product.

This involves being transparent about the use of AI enhancements and ensuring that any changes made do not mislead the consumer about the product’s quality, functionality, or features.


Is it real? Or is it AI generated?   –  This one is real.


The Dark Side of AI in Product Photography


Now let’s talk about recognizing and addressing Artificial Intelligence’s potential downsides.


The Risk of Misrepresentation


One of the primary concerns with using AI in product photography is the risk of misrepresenting the product.

AI’s ability to alter images can sometimes cross the line from enhancing reality to creating a false representation.

People are leary of believing anything these days.

There are plenty of so called “Deep-Fakes”, which are creations of AI that people believed when they were shown on social media.

In AI product photography this could be anything from exaggerating the size of a product to changing its color or texture in a way that doesn’t accurately reflect the actual item.


Consumer Distrust: The Cost of Over-Manipulation


Overly manipulated images lead to consumer distrust.

Consumers value authenticity, presenting them with images that are too perfect or obviously AI-enhanced can backfire.

This skepticism can extend beyond a single product, potentially harming the overall brand reputation and customer loyalty.


Ethical Dilemmas: The Fine Line Between Enhancement and Deception


The ethical challenges of AI in product photography revolve around the fine line between enhancing an image and deceiving the consumer.

Marketers must navigate this territory carefully, considering not just the legal implications, but also the moral responsibility they hold towards their customers.


Jacks, photographed for article on Product Photography for Games and Toys.
Not AI – This image was produced in camera and used manual editing.


Balancing AI Use with Ethical Practices


It’s essential to consider how to balance the incredible capabilities of AI with ethical practices.

This section outlines strategies for marketing professionals to responsibly harness AI while maintaining authenticity and trust.


Developing a Framework for Ethical AI Use



Be open about the use of AI in product imagery. If certain aspects of a product image have been enhanced or altered using AI, consider disclosing this information.

Transparency fosters trust and aligns with ethical marketing practices.


Guidelines and Limits:

Establish internal guidelines for AI use.

Determine what level of AI enhancement is acceptable and where it crosses the line into misrepresentation.

Setting clear boundaries ensures consistency and ethical compliance.


Maintaining Authenticity in AI-Enhanced Images


Realism Over Perfection:

Aim for realistic enhancements that improve image quality without distorting the product’s true nature.

Avoid over-polishing images to the point where they lose their authenticity.


Feedback Loop:

Regularly gather feedback from consumers about their perceptions of AI-enhanced images.

Understanding consumer sentiment can guide the ethical use of AI in product photography.


Legal Compliance and Ethical Responsibility


Stay Informed:

Keep abreast of legal standards and industry practices regarding AI in advertising.

Regularly review the FTC guidelines to ensure compliance.


Ethical Decision-Making:

Involve a diverse team in the decision-making process around AI use.

Different perspectives can help identify potential ethical issues before they arise.


Best Practices for AI in Product Photography


Selective Enhancement:

Use AI for tasks like background removal or color correction, but avoid altering core aspects of the product.


Quality Control:

Implement a quality control process to review AI-enhanced images, ensuring they accurately represent the product.


By adopting these practices, you, as a marketing professional can leverage the power of AI product photography while upholding ethical standards and consumer trust.


AI product photography example by Dall-E - created in December of 2023 - note the model has no skin texture.
AI Model holding a jar of skin cream. Does this look realistic to you?

AI Photography Use: My Personal Experience


I’ve been sharing information that you may not have thought about, but now I’d like to examine some of my personal experiences with AI uses in product photography.

My hope is by providing these insights, both the successes and challenges, it will offer you additional understanding when it comes to integrating AI technologies in this field.


Success Stories: AI Enhancing Product Photography



Over the last few years, Adobe Photoshop has expanded the capabilities of AI significantly within their software.

You now have the option to cut out a subject, transform the sky or background and even generate AI created objects in the project, all with the click of a button.

This ability helps the creative to achieve works that would previously taken hours, in mere minutes.


Practical Applications:

In my own product image editing workflow I sometimes use AI for tasks like cutouts, extending or changing backgrounds.

What I have learned in this time is that there are many cases when AI doesn’t meet my expectations for my work.


Challenges and Lessons Learned


How A Cutout Works:

First, allow me to explain how an image cutout works for those of you who may not understand.

The object isn’t actually cut out – an editor simply removes the background by “painting it” away.

This painting is called a mask, anything painted black is invisible. Anything painted white still shows.

So when you “cut-out” an object, you are basically creating a mask where the object is white and the background is removed by painting it black.


AI Cutouts:

There have been times when a cutout mask misses a part of the subject, or extends the outline of the object to incorporate some of the background.

While you can tune the masking, that can be hit or miss. And usually I could have done as good if not a better job using the Photoshop Pen tool to create a better outline.

I often find myself going into the cutout layer to fine tune the masking which removes the background.


Background Replacements:

Once you have a cutout, it is easy to replace the background or sky by dropping another image behind the cutout.

However, these replacements often have their own problems.

AI may not include a shadow, creating the feel that the product was cut out and slapped on another picture.

AI does not usually change any color cast that shows on a product from the original background.

These small details might not be obvious, but they cause a feeling of manipulation which makes the image untrustworthy.


Limitations and Realism:

No matter if it is AI, or the heavy hand on a photo editor,  overly manipulated images don’t “feel real”.

Above you saw an image of a model holding an open jar of skin cream.

When you look at that image, does it “feel real” to you?

The AI did an excellent job creating light and shadow, whisps of hair and even the gradient light on the glass container.

If your brand’s logo was on the container, would you consider using this to promote your brand.

I hope not!


AI-Generated Models:

Think of the money your company could save if you didn’t need to hire a photographer and a model!

Now think of the money your company could lose if people started to realize your marketing images were fake.

AI-created images have shortcomings, and in this case, if you felt it, but wasn’t quite sure why – look at the model’s skin.

There are no skin pores. The eyes lack true depth. There is no texture to her at all.  Plus … those eyebrows! Definitely not real.

This point underscores the current limitations of AI.

Will these be corrected as time goes on, probably, but does that mean you should use them?

Brand Trust Issues:

As an example of advertising fraud involving images, in 2009, an Olay cosmetics ad for Definity eye cream showed the model Twiggy looking wrinkle-free. Amazing for a woman who was 60 years old.

It turned out the ads were retouched, according to The Guardian.

The British advertising regulator ASA banned the ad after there were more than 700 complaints against it.

The digitally-altered images provided a “misleading impression of the effect the product could achieve.”

Olay’s parent company Procter & Gamble responded that it was “routine practice to use post-production techniques to correct for lighting and other minor photographic deficiencies before publishing the final shots as part of an advertising campaign.”

Despite the claim, the company was forced to remove the ad and replace the images with unretouched versions.


While that case did not involve AI, it does show that consumers can tell when something is off.

I’ve said it before.

Misuse of AI in product photography will lead to consumer distrust and/or possible legal issues.


Another AI image of a model showing off jewelry. Again, note there are no skin pores or texture.
Another AI model example.

AI’s Limitations in Product Authenticity


While AI offers remarkable capabilities in product photography, it’s important to acknowledge its limitations in capturing the true essence of a product.


The Importance of Human Touch


Artistic Insight:

AI algorithms, while powerful, lack the artistic insight and emotional intuition that human photographers bring to the table.

This human touch is crucial in capturing the story and emotion behind a product, elements that AI currently cannot replicate.


Understanding Consumer Connection:

Photographers understand the emotional and psychological connections consumers have with products.

This understanding is vital in creating images that not only display a product but also resonate with consumers on a deeper level.


Shortcomings of AI in Capturing Product Essence


Texture and Detail:

AI may struggle to accurately represent the texture and finer details of products, which are essential in conveying quality and authenticity.

Contextual Understanding:

AI often lacks the contextual understanding necessary to present a product in its best light.

The way a product is used, its significance in different cultures, and its emotional appeal are aspects that AI might not fully capture.

After all, AI does not use actually use the products, so it’s understanding will be limited.

Consumer Perception of AI-Generated Images


The way consumers perceive AI-generated images versus traditional photography is crucial in understanding the impact of AI in product photography.


Comparing AI and Traditional Photography


Quality and Appeal:

Consumers value the authenticity that traditional photography provides.

Studies show that while consumers might be impressed by the technical prowess of AI-generated images, they come across as less genuine.

Especially if those images lack the nuances of real-life photography.


Implications on Trust and Brand Authenticity


Building Trust:

The use of AI in product photography should be balanced to maintain consumer trust.

Over-reliance on AI-generated images, especially when they significantly differ from the actual product, can lead to trust issues.

Maintaining Brand Authenticity:

Brands need to carefully consider how the use of AI-generated images aligns with their overall brand image and values.

Authenticity in product representation is key to maintaining a loyal customer base and attracting new consumers.

As we conclude this journey through the ethical lens of AI in product photography, it’s clear that AI brings a transformative potential to the field.

Its capabilities in enhancing efficiency, creativity, and precision are undeniable.

However, as we have explored, this technology must be balanced with ethical considerations and a commitment to truthfulness, especially in line with the FTC’s Truth in Advertising Laws.


The future of AI in product photography is bright, teeming with possibilities for innovation and advancement.

Yet, it comes with the responsibility of maintaining the authenticity and trust that are the bedrock of consumer-brand relationships.

Marketing professionals and photographers alike must navigate this evolving landscape with a keen awareness of both the power and the pitfalls of AI.


For those eager to explore the vast potential of AI in their product photography, the journey is both exciting and challenging.

Just remember the cost savings of a generated photo pale in comparison to the ethical standards that uphold brand integrity and consumer trust.


Are you looking to harness the power of AI in your product photography while ensuring that your images remain authentic and true to your brand?

I’m here to help!

Contact me for a free, no-obligation consultation on your product imagery needs.

Together, we can explore how AI can enhance your product photography, ensuring that it not only captures attention but also maintains the trust and loyalty of your customers.

Let’s create images that truly represent your products and resonate with your audience.


Discover How Professional Photography Can Elevate Your Brand

Get a Custom Quote Tailored to Your Specific Needs

Hand clicking on a'Submit' button for a free consultation on commercial photography

Take a minute to fill out the form below. Doing so will help me understand your product photography needs. Once I receive your information, I'll reach out to you personally to discuss the project in more detail and create a customized quote for you.

You may also text me at: 410-596-4127 or E-mail me at: tom@tomcrowl.com